New York Life vs Minnesota Life Insurance (Securian)

Comprehensive side-by-side comparison of indexed universal life insurance companies

Updated 2025
Independent Analysis
Professional Ratings

New York Life

Founded: 1845

New York, NY

Financial Strength Ratings

AM Best A++
S&P AA+
Moody's Aaa
Assets
$400 billion+ assets
IUL Experience
0+ years
Products
0
Avg Cap Rate
N/A

Key Strengths

Largest mutual company
Does NOT offer IUL
Offers UL and VUL, but no indexed UL
Visit New York Life Website →

Minnesota Life Insurance (Securian)

Founded: 1880

St. Paul, Minnesota

Financial Strength Ratings

AM Best A+
S&P AA-
Moody's A1
Assets
$5.5 billion+ assets
IUL Experience
10+ years
Products
3
Avg Cap Rate
9%

Key Strengths

Same as Securian (#15)
Eclipse Accumulator II IUL, Eclipse Protector II, Orion IUL
145 years operating
Visit Minnesota Life Insurance (Securian) Website →

Detailed Feature Comparison

Feature New York Life Minnesota Life Insurance (Securian)
Founded 1845 1880
Headquarters New York, NY St. Paul, Minnesota
Assets Under Management $400 billion+ assets $5.5 billion+ assets
Years in IUL Business 0+ years 10+ years
Number of IUL Products 0 3
Typical Cap Rate Range N/A - N/A 8% - 10%
Participation Rates N/A 120%
Minimum Premium N/A $5,000 annual
Issue Ages N/A 0-85 years
Underwriting Speed N/A 2-4 weeks

Similar Companies

Northwestern Mutual

AM Best: A++

$655 billion+ AUM

Compare →

MassMutual

AM Best: A++

$950 billion+ life protection in force AUM

Compare →

Guardian Life

AM Best: A++

$1.6 billion dividend allocation 2025 AUM

Compare →

State Farm

AM Best: A++

$200 billion+ AUM

Compare →

Similar Companies

Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company

AM Best: A+

$42 billion (Fortune 500) AUM

Compare →

Protective Life Insurance Company

AM Best: A+

$120 billion AUM

Compare →

Securian Financial (Minnesota Life)

AM Best: A+

$5.5 billion+ AUM

Compare →

Midland National Life Insurance Company

AM Best: A+

$55 billion AUM

Compare →

📞 Call Now Get Free Illustration